A Guide to Hiring Reputation Management Consultants

The experience people have with a company influences how they feel about it. In fact, 83% of customers must be able to trust the brand before they buy from them. For this reason, it is critical to build a positive online reputation. Companies must also manage negative content as quickly as possible.

But many companies do not have the resources required to manage their online presence. Reputation management consultants can help.

Understanding reputation management

Reputation management shapes how people view-and feel about-a person, business, or brand. To manage a reputation, companies must be proactive and take steps to address how the public sees them-on- and offline.

Think of it as a strategy designed to enhance an organization’s positive attributes and reduce any bad publicity that could damage it.

In today’s world, even the smallest misstep can wreak havoc. In August 2019, a passenger tweeted a photo of a woman on an EasyJet flight from London to Geneva sitting on backless seat.

The tweet went viral, getting over 40,000 likes and 20,000 retweets. The European Aviation Safety Agency and International Air Trade Association were tagged in the post. EasyJet’s initial response was immediate (within 15 minutes), but it missed the mark. They asked the poster to delete the picture, which angered Twitter users.

The airline’s spokesperson later clarified that the passenger did not use the inoperative seat during the flight, but the damage was done. EasyJet turned a minor issue into a top PR crisis by mishandling the situation.

Websites, social media, and online reviews are rampant. Potential customers have more access to information about your company than ever before. They can discover all about you and your company in mere minutes. Your brand reputation affects your company’s sales, ability to recruit talent, and overall performance in the market. One critical review or the slightest negative PR can create a reputation crisis.

It takes a lot longer to clean up a mess than it does to make one. Sometimes, you’ll need help. That’s where online reputation management consultants (ORM consultants) come in.

What is a reputation management consultant?

Reputation management consultants are strategic partners who help individuals and businesses shape their online narrative. They leverage expertise in search engine optimization, social media content, and online reviews to help client’s develop a positive online image and address challenges head-on. From content marketing to addressing negative publicity, a reputation consultant empowers clients to build and maintain a presence that promotes trust and credibility with the right audience.

How their reputation management consultants differ from traditional PR and marketing agencies

Reputation management consultants differ from traditional public relations and marketing agencies in several key ways:

• Proactive vs. reactive: Reputation management professionals focus on proactive strategies to build and maintain a positive online presence. Traditional PR and marketing agencies often focus on publicity generation or reactive reputation management during a crisis.

• Online focus: While traditional agencies may dabble in it, online reputation experts specialize in digital spaces, such as search results, social media profiles, and review platforms. They understand the unique dynamics of these environments.

• Custom solutions: A reputation manager consultant offers personalized strategies, considering the individual needs and challenges of each client, whereas traditional agencies might rely on broader, less customized approaches.

• Data-guided: Reputation management consultants use sophisticated tools and analytics to monitor online mentions, track sentiment, and measure the success of their strategies, providing clients with tangible results and actionable insights.

In essence, reputation management consultants act as strategic partners, proactively safeguarding the client’s online reputation and empowering them to control their brand’s narrative.

Key services offered by reputation management consultants

Reputation management consultants offer a suite of services designed for each client’s unique situation. Their process typically begins with an online reputation audit. This audit serves as a diagnostic tool to pinpoint problems that need to be addressed immediately.

Online reputation audit

An online reputation audit assesses consumers’ perception of the brand on- and offline. The audit provides a holistic view of your online image and prioritizes issues that need repair. During this audit, reputation management consultants will research your brand by checking:

• Review sites: Customer feedback and star ratings on sites like Google My Business, Yelp, TripAdvisor, and other specific review websites.

• Social media platforms: Evaluate sentiment on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, LinkedIn, and other similar platforms.

• Search engine results pages (SERPs): Analyze what comes up when people search for your name or related words. Examples are news articles, blog posts, discussions in forums, and updates on social media.

Through this process, the consultant will find positive content you can use and negative feedback that needs to be addressed.

Customized strategy development

Reputation management consultants can create a plan that fits into your business strategy. Unlike one-size-fits-all methods, these custom plans take your unique goals, audience, and industry into account.

The first step in creating this plan is to understand your brand values, audience, and competitors. Then, reputation management consultants can use a range of strategies to improve your online presence and achieve your goals. This strategy may includes tactics like content removal (if possible), addressing complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau, and other reputation issues that that impact the brand image.

Monitoring and reporting

Reputation management is not a set-it-and-forget-it task. It is an ongoing process that requires constant attention. Reputation management experts use special tools to make the job easier. These tools enable consultants to watch brand mentions, track relevant keywords, and monitor online sentiment. This data helps them spot threats quickly and take a proactive approach to correct issues before they get worse.

Consultants will also deliver regular reports on important metrics to show you how well management strategies are working.

The importance of reputation management for large companies

Large companies usually have a broader online presence than small businesses. The public watches them more closely. Many things can impact a large brand’s image, like how employees behave, how well they serve customers, product recalls, or issues about the environment.

Successful reputation management for large companies is much more complex. Image is critical for these companies because it is an important asset that can affect profits. A good reputation attracts investors, increases customer retention, and creates a competitive advantage. But a poor one can lead to significant financial loss, legal issues, and serious damage to long-term brand equity.

The tangible impact of reputation on revenue, customer loyalty, employee engagement, and investor confidence

The financial impact of a negative review is difficult to pinpoint, as it varies significantly depending on several factors. However, research suggests:

• A negative review can deter up to 80% of potential customers, costing businesses significant revenue.

• A single bad review can cost a business an average of $3,000 per year.

• It is estimated that bad reviews cost businesses roughly $200 billion annually.

A strong reputation, built on trust and credibility, can help a company generate higher revenue. Customers are more likely to choose a business with a solid reputation, even if their prices are higher than competitors. When people trust a brand, they are more likely to buy from it again and tell their friends and family about it. Word-of-mouth marketing is an invaluable source of additional profit.

Having a strong reputation also helps companies attract and keep skilled workers. Talented people want to join ethical companies that share their values. This can lead to happy employees, better work, and a healthy company culture.

The unique reputation management challenges faced by large companies

Large companies have many benefits from their size and reach. However, they also face special challenges in managing their reputation. It is harder for them to maintain a consistent brand reputation across different departments, locations, and online platforms. If just one employee makes a mistake or if a local problem arises, it can turn into a major PR crisis if not handled properly.

The 24/7 news cycle and the rise of social media make these challenges even tougher. Negative news or complaints can go viral in just a few hours. This means that news can reach a global audience before the company can respond. Because of this constant attention, big companies need to be alert and proactive.

To maintain a strong brand reputation, businesses need an effective strategy. This includes having a team that watches over their online mentions and responds. They also need adequate resources.

The need for proactive reputation management to prevent crises and mitigate damage

Reacting to a crisis is not enough. Proactive reputation management means putting in regular effort to create a strong online presence and interact with stakeholders. This involves creating content that highlights the brand’s values and positive contributions. Companies must listen to customer feedback and reply with compassion when concerns come up. Being open and ethical is crucial.

Hiring reputation management consultants

Finding a good consultant can make a significant impact on your online presence. But you need a partner who understands your specific needs, industry, and target audience. An expert consultant will team up with you to create and carry out a plan that will address your critical issues.

When looking for a consultant, consider their experience and methods. Choose a company that has a successful track record of success in your sector and focuses on ethical strategies to get long-lasting results.

Evaluating reputation manager consultants: What makes a good fit?

When you talk to potential consultants, how can you tell which one is best for you? Don’t just look at prices or service lists. Find a partner who understands your unique needs and goals.

Pay attention to how well they understand your specific objectives. Does their plan tackle your primary concerns? Is their method suited to your industry and audience? Do they show a solid understanding of your brand and its values?

The right consultant should feel like part of your team. They need to be quick to respond, be open in communication, and truly care about your success. Look for a partner who wants to build a long-term relationship and give ongoing support as your needs change.

Questions to ask potential consultants

Asking the right questions from the start helps make sure you both agree and increases the chances of a good working relationship.

Here are some key questions to consider asking a reputation management consultant during the hiring process:

• Can you walk me through your process for assessing a client’s current online reputation?

• What tools and technologies do you use for monitoring and managing online presence?

• How do you handle negative reviews or comments about a client?

• How do you measure the success of your management efforts?

• Can you provide case studies or examples of clients you’ve helped successfully?

• How do you stay up-to-date with changes in search algorithms and social media platforms?

• What’s your crisis management strategy for sudden reputation threats?

• How do you balance transparency and privacy?

• What’s your policy on ethical practices?

• How do you coordinate with other departments or agencies (like PR or marketing)?

• What’s your typical timeline for seeing results?

• How do you report progress and results to clients?

Common pitfalls in reputation management and how to avoid them

Large companies face several major pitfalls.

One of the biggest is appearing inauthentic or disingenuous in their efforts to improve public perception. This can happen when a company’s actions don’t match its stated values or when it tries to cover up mistakes instead of addressing them openly. To avoid this, companies should focus on aligning their actions with their messaging and being transparent about both successes and failures.

Another common issue is responding too slowly to emerging crises or negative publicity. Today’s digital world runs at a rapid pace. Delays can allow problems to spiral out of control. Companies can prevent this problem by having a solid crisis management plan in place and monitoring their online presence closely. Overreacting to minor issues is also a risk because it draws unnecessary attention to insignificant problems. A measured, proportional response is usually best.

Many large companies struggle with inconsistent messaging across different departments or regions, which can confuse customers and damage credibility. Instead, companies should establish clear communication guidelines and align teams with reputation management guidelines.

Last, but not least, failing to engage with customers genuinely on social media platforms or forums can make a company seem out of touch. Building genuine connections with audiences through thoughtful, personalized interactions can go a long way in maintaining a positive reputation.

Addressing misconceptions about reputation management services

Many people have misconceptions about reputation management services that can lead to unrealistic expectations or mistrust. One common myth is that these services can completely erase negative information online, which isn’t true or ethical. But reputation management focuses on promoting positive content and addressing issues constructively.

Another misconception is that it’s only for covering up mistakes or manipulating public opinion. In reality, effective reputation management is about building and maintaining a positive image through honest communication and good practices.

Some believe these services are only for big companies or celebrities, but they can benefit individuals and small businesses too. There’s also a false idea that reputation management is a one-time fix rather than an ongoing process. It’s important for service providers to be clear about what they can and can’t do, emphasizing ethical practices and long-term strategies. They should educate clients on the importance of consistent, authentic communication and actions that align with their desired reputation.

Providers can share case studies and explain their methods to show how reputation management works in practice. It’s also helpful to highlight how these services can be proactive, preventing issues before they arise, rather than just reacting to problems.

Ensuring ethical practices in reputation management

Large companies can ensure ethical practices in reputation management by focusing on transparency and honesty. They should set clear guidelines that prioritize truthful communication and reject any attempts to mislead the public.

It’s crucial to address problems head-on rather than hiding them. Companies should take responsibility for their actions, admit mistakes when they occur, and show how they’re working to fix issues. They can build trust by being open about their practices and sharing both successes and challenges with stakeholders.

Ethical reputation management also means respecting privacy laws and not using personal data inappropriately. Companies should avoid tactics like fake reviews or misleading social media campaigns. Instead, they should focus on earning positive attention through genuine improvements in their products, services, and corporate behavior. It’s important to engage with customers and critics alike respectfully, listening to concerns and responding thoughtfully.

Companies can also prove their commitment to ethics by supporting causes that align with their values. In addition, their actions should be consistent across all departments and regions. Regular training for employees on ethical communication and decision-making can help ensure these principles are followed throughout the organization.

Measuring the success of your reputation management efforts

Reputation management is like other business plans. You can’t just have a strategy and hope everything goes well. Companies must measure the plan to gauge how well it works and how to improve it.

Key performance indicators (KPIs) for reputation management

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for reputation management strategy help companies measure the effectiveness of their efforts. One important KPI is sentiment analysis, which tracks the tone of mentions about the company online, categorizing them as positive, negative, or neutral.

Another useful measure is share of voice, which compares how often a company is mentioned versus its competitors. Net Promoter Score (NPS) is a valuable KPI that measures customer loyalty and the likelihood they would recommend the company.

Online review ratings and the volume of reviews can reveal customer satisfaction and engagement. Website traffic and social media follower growth can show increased interest in the brand. Engagement rates on social media posts help gauge how well content resonates with audiences. Media mention quality and quantity track the company’s presence in news outlets and blogs.

Response time to customer inquiries or complaints is crucial for maintaining an excellent reputation. Brand awareness surveys can reveal how well-known and understood the company is among target audiences. Reputation management efforts can lead to higher conversion rates, such as increased sales or job applications.

Case study: A successful reputation management campaign

Examining case studies of successful reputation management campaigns can offer invaluable insights into what works and how strategic approaches can yield remarkable results. These real-world examples show the transformative power of effective reputation management across various industries.

One notable case study involves another airline that faced severe backlash after a passenger incident went viral.

United Airlines, one of the world’s major carriers, found itself in the eye of a social media storm. On April 9, 2017-a seemingly routine flight-passengers buckled up, and then… chaos. A video went viral, capturing a violent altercation between a passenger and United Airlines staff. The scene was distressing: a 69-year-old passenger named David Dao forcibly removed from the aircraft, dragged down the aisle, and injured in the process. The internet erupted with a rabid flurry of concerned citizens.

Now, let’s break down this high-altitude drama:

The Incident: David Dao’s unfortunate experience-caught on camera by another passenger-was like a lightning strike. The video spread fast. People were outraged, questioning passenger rights, airline policies, and basic humanity.

The Backlash: Social media became a tempest. Angry tweets, memes, and hashtags (#BoycottUnited) swirled. United Airlines faced a PR hurricane.

The Crisis Management Plan: United Airlines didn’t just hunker down. They took swift action:

• Sincere Apologies: They established a dialogue with affected passengers, offering direct apologies. Imagine a CEO saying, “We made a grave mistake. Let’s make this right.”

• Compensations and Amends: They didn’t just serve peanuts. UA served justice. Compensation efforts played a vital role in restoring customer faith.

• Transparency: United Airlines didn’t hide. They communicated openly, explaining what went wrong and how they would fix it.

• Customer-Centric Approach: They put passengers first. Imagine flight attendants handing out empathy instead of pretzels.

• The Trust Rebuild: United Airlines knew trust was their lifeline. By addressing individual grievances, they rebuilt trust-one passenger at a time.

• The Takeoff After the Storm: Did they succeed? The turbulence settled. United Airlines learned that crisis management isn’t about avoiding storms, but flying through them with grace.

Do you want a free reputation audit?

Reputation management consultants help protect and improve your online reputation. Their services are especially helpful for big companies because it helps them grow revenue, keep customers, and establish trust with investors.

The Brand Auditors offers reputation management consulting services. Click the button at the bottom of the page to get a free reputation audit.

FAQs