How to Conduct a Brand Audit for Professional Services Firms

Elevate your professional services firm with a strategic brand audit. This guide reveals how to align your brand with client needs and outshine competitors.


June 24, 2024

Brand audit for professional services

A brand is currency. For professional service providers, it’s a currency that builds trust with high-value clients. However, many firms struggle to communicate their expertise in a way that attracts profitable customers. It takes more than impressive credentials and a list of testimonials to get the target market’s attention.

Companies that cannot leverage a unique value proposition will lose clients to competitors and experience flat-line growth.

A brand audit for professional services provides a blueprint to help firms communicate a strong, unique selling proposition. The audit process also helps them align brand communication with strategic objectives.

The insights in this post will help professional services firms develop an action plan to overcome their biggest challenges. It will also reveal how to measure brand perception, navigate the trust economy, and outshine competitors.

Table of Contents

    Why is a brand audit for professional services important for providers?

    The audit process helps providers assess their current competitive position and how to better communicate their value to target customers. Providers can also use a comprehensive audit to improve their content marketing, customer service experience, and marketing strategy. These insights are vital for maintaining a competitive edge and ensuring the branding strategy aligns with the firm’s business goals.

    The audit enables service providers to identify inconsistencies in their messaging and image, which can dilute their impact. By addressing any inconsistencies, firms can develop a cohesive brand identity and customer experience. These are key building blocks of customer trust.

    A brand audit for professional services also uncovers opportunities for differentiation. An audit will show providers how to personalize communications and marketing efforts to meet their clients’ expectations.

    There are other benefits of an audit. Let’s look at those now.

    Brand Audit
    Brand Audit

    Professional service brands are the new luxury

    Today’s consumers are not just looking for high-quality products. They’re also craving high-end service solutions. People want personal service experiences and access to experts. Thus, expertise has become the ultimate luxury good, which puts professional services firms in a unique position.

    You might provide legal services to help clients navigate regulatory landscapes. Maybe you’re a consultancy crafting bespoke business solutions. Or you may be a financial advisor safeguarding a family’s legacy. All professional service providers offer clients something money can’t buy. Everyone wants peace of mind and the confidence that comes from knowing they’re getting guidance from the best.

    Professional service firms often struggle to communicate their Unique Value Propositions (UVPs) because they:

    • Sell the intangible: Their expertise and experience are their products, which are harder to showcase than physical items.
    • Sound like everyone else: Many firms use similar jargon and buzzwords, making it difficult to stand out.
    • Focus on features, not benefits: They list their services but don’t clearly explain how those services solve clients’ specific problems.
    • Lack a clear target audience: They try to appeal to everyone instead of focusing on a specific niche.
    • Underestimate the power of emotion: They rely on logic and facts. As a result, service providers forget that clients often decide who to hire based on trust and connection.

    A brand audit for professional services can help firms overcome these challenges. An audit helps providers clarify the firm’s unique value and define the most profitable target audience. Therefore, they can craft compelling messaging that resonates emotionally with potential clients.

    The trust premium

    A professional services brand should reflect quality, reliability, and ethical conduct. Clients will pay a premium if they know their investment will give them results and a partnership built on trust. This “trust premium” allows firms to command higher fees and promotes long-term client loyalty.

    A brand audit for professional services can identify the key trust factors clients consider when selecting their providers. Then you can use those factors to enhance your brand’s identity and messaging.

    The reputation economy

    Here’s how the “reputation economy” affects professional services firms:

    1. Client acquisition: Today’s clients go online to research, evaluate, and select professional service providers. A strong reputation, built on positive reviews and recommendations, significantly influences their decision-making process. A firm with a stellar reputation will attract high-value clients who will pay a premium for quality services.
    2. Talent attraction and retention: A positive reputation also plays a crucial role in attracting and keeping top talent. Skilled professionals want to work for firms that are well-regarded in their industry. A strong employer brand can be a powerful magnet for attracting the best and brightest.
    3. Competitive advantage: In a crowded marketplace, a strong reputation can be a key differentiator. It sets a firm apart from competitors and gives it a competitive edge. This can lead to increased market share, higher fees, and greater resilience in the face of economic downturns.
    4. Risk mitigation: A solid reputation can act as a buffer during times of crisis. When a firm faces a negative event, a strong reputation can help minimize the damage and expedite recovery.
    IMAGE: The impact of a positive or negative customer experience (Click to expand)

    When a brand audit is your secret weapon (And when it isn’t)

    A brand audit for professional services is eye-opening, but it isn’t always the right solution for every business. Understanding the best scenarios can help you determine whether your firm needs an audit.

    When do you need to conduct an audit?

    • Pre-merger or acquisition: An audit can be invaluable when two firms join forces. It helps identify potential conflicts in brand values, messaging, or the target audience. An audit also provides an opportunity to revise the collective brand strategy to ensure a successful transition.
    • When rebranding a business: An audit provides an understanding of the current brand versus its future goals. These insights guide the development of a new brand identity.
    • Post-crisis: An audit can be a lifeline after a crisis that damages your firm’s reputation. It helps businesses assess the extent of the damage and develop a strategy for rebuilding trust and credibility.
    • Stagnant growth: A brand audit can uncover issues that may be hindering growth. Examples are outdated messaging, declining brand awareness, or a lack of differentiation.
    • New leadership: When new leadership takes over, you need a fresh perspective on the firm’s identity and positioning. An audit can help align the brand with the new leadership’s vision and strategic direction.

    When NOT to conduct an audit

    • Lack of commitment: An audit is an investment of time, resources, and financial commitment. If your firm isn’t willing to invest in the audit’s long-term action plan, it may not be worth the effort.
    • Short-term focus: A brand audit is a long-term strategy for building a sustainable business. It may not be the most efficient solution if you’re looking for a quick fix to a specific problem.

    An audit is not a magic bullet. But when used strategically, it can be a powerful catalyst for growth and transformation.

    Does your professional services firm need a brand audit
    Does your professional services firm need a brand audit

    The hidden gems: Unconventional brand audit components

    To make the greatest impact, a brand audit for professional services must explore the unconventional components. Specifically, these are the internal and external brand elements.

    Digital footprint analysis

    Analyzing your website and social media channels is essential. But a comprehensive brand audit for professional services goes further. You must examine your digital footprint across the entire online landscape. Reviews on platforms like Google and Yelp, discussions on social media groups, and mentions of your firm by competitors are examples. Web analytics can also give you valuable insight into the services and content that interest potential customers.

    These sources offer candid feedback that reveals how potential customers and current client perceive your company. By listening to the voices online, you can identify trends, address potential reputation issues, and find untapped growth opportunities.

    Voice of employee (VoE) research

    Your employees are the backbone of your operations. They’re also brand ambassadors. Understanding their perceptions of your brand ensures alignment between your internal culture and external messaging.

    VoE research involves surveys, focus groups, and one-on-one interviews. These gauge employee engagement, satisfaction, and brand advocacy. They help identify disconnects and empower employees to champion your brand.

    Client advisory boards

    Creating a client advisory board invites a select group of valued clients to share their candid feedback, ideas, and expectations. These lines of communication promote a deeper understanding of client needs, identify emerging trends, and allow you to address concerns proactively. They also reinforce your commitment to strengthening client relationships.

    Data storytelling

    Data visualization plays a crucial role in making brand audit findings accessible and actionable. It helps stakeholders grasp the big picture, understand the implications of the data, and make decisions based on visual evidence.

    Here are some key benefits of data visualization in a brand audit for professional services:

    • Simplified communication: Complex data sets, such as survey results or web analytics, can be difficult to interpret in their raw form. Data visualization transforms this information into digestible visuals. As a result, it’s easier to communicate findings to stakeholders who may not be data experts.
    • Enhanced understanding: Visual representations of data help reveal patterns, trends, and correlations hidden in raw data. This deeper understanding enables you to identify strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for your brand.
    • Improved decision-making: By visually presenting data, you can quickly identify areas that require attention or investment. This enables you to make data-driven decisions that are more likely to lead to positive outcomes.
    • Increased engagement: Data visualizations are more engaging and memorable than plain text or spreadsheets. They can capture attention, spark conversations, and encourage stakeholders to take action based on the insights presented.

    A brand audit for professional services: A step-by-step guide

    A brand audit for professional services requires a structured approach. This playbook outlines a three-phase process that combines in-depth research, analysis, and strategic design to elevate your firm.

    Brand Audit Steps for professional services
    Brand audit Steps for professional services

    Phase one: Discovery and differentiation

    In this first step, gather crucial evidence to diagnose your brand’s current state of health. This goes beyond surface-level research and involves:

    • In-depth stakeholder interviews: Engaging in honest conversations with partners, employees, and leadership. The goal is to understand their perceptions, values, and pain points related to the brand’s products and services.
    • Client immersion: Conduct in-depth interviews with current, past, and even prospective clients to gauge their experiences, expectations, and perceptions.
    • Secret shopper experiences: Anonymously engage with your firm as a potential client to experience it as clients do.
    • Social listening and sentiment analysis: Use social listening tools to monitor online conversations, reviews, and mentions. These gauge sentiment and identify potential reputation issues.
    • Competitive landscape audit: Analyze competitors’ positioning, messaging, and online presence. Doing so helps you understand your firm’s unique strengths and weaknesses in the market.

    Phase 2: Diagnose and analyze consistency

    Once you’ve gathered data in phase one, it’s time to deconstruct your brand’s anatomy. This involves:

    • SWOT analysis: An examination of your brand’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats to identify areas for improvement and growth potential.
    • Perceptual mapping: Visualize your company in relation to competitors using key attributes.
    • Archetype analysis: Identify your brand’s archetypal persona (e.g., the Sage, the Hero, the Magician). Doing so can help you ensure your messaging and visuals align with your core identity.
    • Messaging and voice audit: Analyzing your brand’s communication style across all channels ensures consistency and clarity.
    • Visual identity assessment: Evaluate your logo, website, marketing materials, and other visual elements. Doing so ensures they reflect your brand’s personality and values.

    Phase 3: Design and direction

    This phase focuses on developing actionable recommendations that guide your brand’s evolution.

    • Refined positioning statement: A concise, unique value proposition and target audience.
    • Messaging framework: A set of guidelines and key messages that ensure consistent communication across all channels.
    • Creative briefs: Detailed briefs for designers, copywriters, and marketers. These guide the development of new brand assets and campaigns.
    • Implementation plan: A prioritized list of action items with timelines and assigned responsibilities to prioritize and execute recommendations.
    • Measurement and evaluation: Develop key performance indicators (KPIs) to track progress and measure the impact of enhancements.

    Are there any industry-specific considerations to keep in mind when conducting a brand audit for professional services?

    Yes. An audit for professional services should consider industry reputation, client relationships, service quality benchmarks, and compliance standards. Understanding client expectations and market trends also helps professional service providers improve their growth strategy.

    The challenge of brand consistency in large professional services firms

    Large professional services firms, especially those with multiple locations, often face a unique challenge: maintaining brand consistency. With teams spread across different offices, regions, or even countries, ensuring a unified brand message and experience can be challenging. Inconsistencies in messaging, visual identity, and client interactions can erode brand trust and dilute the firm’s overall impact.

    Here’s how this challenge often manifests:

    Messaging misalignment: Different offices or departments may develop their own marketing materials, presentations, or website content. This design-by-silo approach leads to variations in tone, messaging, and value proposition, which can weaken the brand’s overall impact.

    Visual identity discrepancies: Variations in logo usage, color palettes, fonts, and other design elements can create a fragmented visual identity. This lack of cohesion creates confusion across different touchpoints.

    Inconsistent client experiences: Clients often interact with different offices or departments and encounter varying levels of service quality and communication styles. This dilutes the overall brand experience, which can undermine client trust and loyalty.

    How a brand audit can help

    A brand auditor for professional services can help large firms struggling with consistency. Here’s how:

    Identifying inconsistencies: The audit process looks at all customer touchpoints. It uncovers misaligned messaging, visuals, and user experiences across different locations and departments.

    Developing style guidelines: Based on audit findings, companies can create or update brand guidelines. These guidelines direct logo usage, messaging, tone of voice, visual identity elements, and client service standards to unify the firm.

    Training and communication: The audit recommendations can include training to ensure that all employees, regardless of location, understand guidelines. This promotes shared ownership and responsibility for the firm’s success.

    Centralized brand management: Implementing a centralized system or team can help ensure consistent application of guidelines across all offices and departments. This includes reviewing and approving all marketing materials, presentations, and client communications to maintain integrity.

    Regular audits: Scheduling brand audits annually or bi-annually can help identify potential issues before they become major problems.

    Establishing KPI Benchmarks (Click to expand)

    Key performance indicators (KPIs) for professional services

    An audit isn’t just about qualitative insights and subjective opinions. To gauge your brand’s effectiveness, you must track key performance indicators (KPIs). These metrics provide a quantitative measure of your brand, its impact, and overall performance in the marketplace.

    Here are some of the most important KPIs for professional services:

    Client lifetime value (CLV)

    CLV measures the total revenue a client generates for your firm over the entire duration of their relationship. CLV considers the long-term value of repeat business and potential referrals. A high CLV indicates a healthy brand that fosters loyalty and enduring client relationships.

    CLV = (Average Revenue per Client) x (Average Client Lifespan)

    Referral rate

    In the world of professional services, word-of-mouth marketing is invaluable. Your referral rate measures the percentage of new clients gained through referrals from existing or past clients. A high referral rate is a testament to your brand’s reputation and the trust it has built within your network.

    Employee net promoter score (eNPS)

    Your employees are your brand’s most authentic advocates. The eNPS measures how likely your employees are to recommend your firm as a successful workplace. A high eNPS shows a positive internal culture, strong employee engagement, and a workforce that is proud to represent your firm.

    Share of voice (SoV)

    The SoV metric measures your brand’s visibility and prominence in the industry conversation. It tracks how often your brand is mentioned online, in the media, and in industry discussions compared to your competitors. A high SoV shows your company is top-of-mind for potential clients and influential within your field.

    Your professional service brand’s transformation starts now

    A brand audit for professional services is a strategic investment in your firm’s future. The process can help you grow, connect with clients, and become an expertise leader.

    Ready to take the next step? We’re here to help. Schedule a complimentary consultation to learn more.

    Chris Fulmer PCM-Brand Auditors

    Chris Fulmer, PCM®

    Brand Strategist | Managing Director

    Chris has over 15 years of experience in brand development and marketing. He has designed strategies across various industries, such as technology, B2B services, and healthcare. His expertise includes brand positioning, competitive analysis, content marketing, and web development.

    Click to learn more about Chris

    Are you ready to find out how a brand audit can transform your business?

    Our brand audit process is a comprehensive analysis designed to help companies optimize performance.

    • Increase ROI on lead generation and sales conversions.
    • Reduce marketing expenses.
    • Strengthen brand positioning to become more competitive.

    We guarantee satisfaction or get your money back! Schedule a discovery call with a brand auditor to find out more.

    Related Content

    Brand Audit Cost

    How Much Does a Brand Audit Cost?

    Our guide on brand audit fees tells you everything you need to know, including the factors that determine pricing. In under 2 minutes.

    What is a brand audit

    What is a Brand Audit? [Your Path to Increased Profit]

    This post will answer the question 'what is a brand audit?' It will also tell you whether your business needs an audit and the benefits you can get from one.

    How to Do a Brand Audit

    How to Do a Brand Audit: The CMO’s Step-by-Step Guide to Brand Transformation

    Transform your brand with this comprehensive, step-by-step guide designed for CMOs. Learn proven techniques to conduct a brand audit that evaluates brand performance, uncovers actionable insights, and drives meaningful change.